To be honest, I would do away with selling Vp points in the marketplace. Yes, I'm guilty of selling vp myself also, only because I have no real need for it when I treat roleplaying as roleplaying, and don't generally go on the server that commonly anymore due to real-life situations.
That won't help the player-base, but maybe it'll remedy a criticism this server has an issue with. I personally see it as a way of getting money quick I/C without any real roleplaying. (I explain it as my character recieving an endorsement, but it's not good enough and turned out to be disappointing as no company would pay 160,000 on average to an injured athlete.)
I can also see the chargeback doxing scaring off people who visit the forums. Yes, disputing a donation claim for no clear reason may be bad (and illegial?) in itself, but it does not warrant completely revealing information about the user themselves. Doxing itself is illegal, that much I know, correct me if I'm wrong.
Finally, despite my growing time here, I noticed that the admins are not as active as they normally should. Pardon this criticism if you'd like seeing as I've only been on the server for about a few weeks now, but the server's roleplay community and roleplaying can be improved if on-duty time were enforced from the owner and possibly head admins. However, I'd say that the support that I've been given so far during my time here has been helpful and courteous, so I have faith that this server will have a strong staff. It's simply the issue of managing on-duty time.
Spoiler
The only admin experience I had was when I was ..fuckin' young as shit. So take that with an obvious grain of salt.
Btw 15,000 is a lot for beginning. I visited a server where you have to actually work for like 5-10 hrs to get a Regina
Man, I would really love to RP again.. Not just to collect money and be a statwhore.
Hm, that second point I agree with you. One thing I dislike about the server is the lack of roleplaying compared to previous (shut-down) servers I've been in. There were always hubs where you could roleplay with people, whether that be Ten Green Bottles or another bar somewhere in the city.
However, I'll have to disagree with the starting money. A problem I've had with all MTA roleplaying servers was the presence of the starting money itself. When you create a character, you don't create an avatar, you create a actual person with a backstory and their own affairs IMO. If you wish to RP as a former business owner, it wouldn't make sense for them to start out with a simple 6,000 or perhaps even 15,000, but I can understand why starting money is a feature and why I have no problem with it. New Players will obviously exploit receiving massive amounts of cash if they chose so without a good-enough backstory, causing the server's I/C economy to be ultimately destroyed. This comes back to my point about VP points as there are not enough poor people on the server, seeing as this server can break 20 people every once in a while, and thus you'll basically be giving free money to those who do not wish for Vp.
Anyway, I digress, after all these are all my opinions and again, could be taken with a grain of salt considering my lack of experience on this server. That's how I see the server in its present state and a few problems I saw that could draw people away.